Soup-O-Rama: Aroma Serves up More than Mulligatawny

16 Apr

Sunday’s were made for two things: Sunday drives and Sunday dinners. We were lucky enough enjoy both of these Sunday Funday events today with our super cute friends Jay and Suzanne. So, we went on a little tour of coastal Maine before hitting up Aroma in South Portland for some Mulligatawny Soup along with a handful of other delicious Indian dishes.

I’m usually wary of food establishments in strip malls (read: I never go to them), but Aroma has been getting such amazing reviews from other food bloggers and people I trust in the area that I felt it was high time to give it a fair shot. Jay and Suzanne were happy to be part of this experiment too. These two rad kids just moved here from San Francisco less than a year ago, so they know Indian food. In fact, they are very in the know when it comes to Asian cuisine.

Upon first arrival, the place certainly doesn’t look like much. There isn’t even the typical Indian décor that you usually find in restaurants. It’s very simple, just a few tables, the set-up for the buffet area (they do a lunch and dinner buffet most nights) and a television set up in the corner that played some music along with photos of different Indian dishes. The television idea amused us.

We decided not to order the buffet because a) it didn’t look like it was set up and b) I’m not really a buffet person. I have come to find that buffets are usually an invitation to eat more than one should and I can’t help but question the sanitation of buffet operations. Some patrons are gross and I know they don’t wash their hands properly before touch the utensils, but I digress…

We all decided to start out with the vegetable samosas and an order of the Mulligatawny soup.

Vegetable Samosa's

The samosas were some of the best I’ve had, though I thought they were a little heavy on the potato and a little bit light on carrots and peas and other such veggies I have had in ones at other restaurants. It also came with two sauces on the side, one I would liken to mint chutney and another with a hint of plum or some other dark, but sweet fruit.

Mulligatawny Soup

The Mulligatawny Soup was what I came for though. I am humiliated to say that I have never had this soup before, but I always think of the Seinfeld episode where Elaine puts the soup Nazi out of business when she finds his recipes in the armoire that he gives Kramer who then sells it to Elaine who was banished from his restaurant for joking around in line. I’d venture to say that his Mulligatawny Soup wasn’t as good as Aroma’s.

Mulligatawny is a curry-flavored lentil soup. The soup at Aroma has a rich green color and is a really nice blend of spicy and salty. Everyone tasted it and agreed—it was a clear winner. I would definitely order this again. It was well-balanced and the kick after you swallow only added to the depth of its flavors.

After these appetizers we moved on to entrées. Suzanne ordered the Saag Aloo with is potatoes simmered in spices with spinach. Jay ordered the Chicken Kurma, a creamy Indian dish with a special cashew and almond sauce. We also asked for two orders of naan, one regular and one garlic, for the table.

Chicken Kurma (front) & Saag Aloo (back)

Mark ordered the Chicken Tikka Masala (his signature Indian dish). And I decided to order the Chicken Vindalo, because my friend Erhan always raves about how great it is and I was in the mood to keep the spiciness rolling after the amazing soup starter. I ordered a side of raita (yogurt sauce) in case I needed to cut the heat.

Chicken Vindalo

Jay and Suzanne have a little more experience with authentic Indian food than Mark and I do, and they thought their dishes were rather “boring.” Jay said he was longing for more spices to enhance his dish, and the sauce on his Kurma wasn’t as light as he’s had at other places. All in all, it was a bit of a bust for him. Suzanne said much of the same, she longed for something more magical and she felt that it could have used more spices and depth.

Mark on the other hand loves their Tikka Masala, he thinks it’s the best he’s had. My Vindalo wasn’t spicy in the least, and I was worried to order it because it’s supposed to be a “flavorful hot sauce.” I’m not the wimpiest person when it comes to heat, but I’m no rock star either and this was mild in my opinion. Mark tasted it too and felt it was weak. I probably wouldn’t order the Vindalo here again…

I think this is a great addition to the Indian food scene in the greater Portland area. They have some staples of South Indian food that you can’t get other places in town such as Dosa’s, Vada’s and Uthapam’s. It’s worth a try, you never know, you might find a new Indian dish that you really, really like (like their Mulligatawny Soup!!).

Aroma - Authentic Indian Cuisine on Urbanspoon


7 Responses to “Soup-O-Rama: Aroma Serves up More than Mulligatawny”

  1. Malcolm April 16, 2012 at 2:25 am #

    This is discouraging news. We were keeping Aroma in our back pocket for a rainy day. I guess we’ll stick to Bombay Mahal in Brunswick, for now.

    • Eat Here. Go There. April 16, 2012 at 1:18 pm #

      Try some of the South Indian fare that we didn’t or go for the buffet as another commenter recommended. I wouldn’t discount it just yet. Thanks for reading!!

  2. lizzielou67 April 16, 2012 at 11:37 am #

    I really think you made a mistake in not ordering the buffet. Aroma’s buffet is among the freshest, hottest, and most delicious I’ve ever had. Also, if you’d tried the offerings from the buffet, you’d have come across what Aroma’s true strength is, which is South Indian food. Off the top of my head, I think every single one of you ordered a North Indian dish! A huge part of their menu consists of South Indian food, including (at dinner time) dosas. I recommend going back and NOT ordering your usual favorites! Order things that look unfamiliar–this is one of the few places in New England where you can find this cuisine, and they do it beautifully.

    • Eat Here. Go There. April 16, 2012 at 1:17 pm #

      You are right, we didn’t… I went there another time on the fly and had their Mysore Masala Dosa and it was excellent. The buffet was not going when we were in there, but we should pop back in for lunch sometime ($7.95 is a heck of a good deal). I’ll try to get over my fear of buffets so I can try some more variety. Thanks for reading!

  3. shel April 17, 2012 at 8:27 pm #

    I’ll agree with Lizzielou – try the buffet for the Southern Indian dishes – most i’ve tried have been very tasty and everything on the buffet has been fresh/hot and it’s well-maintained. The goat curries and spicy veggie dishes are our favourites. I also like the dosas and biryanis. The sauce with your samosa was probably tamarind, btw. Cheers!

    • Eat Here. Go There. April 18, 2012 at 7:12 pm #

      It was definitely tamarind sauce! I need to get back for the buffet, it’s coming to me HIGHLY recommended. Thanks for reading! Great suggestions.


  1. Public Market Lunch, Part I | Instant Portland - April 16, 2012

    […]  PS: This post is part of the Blog-o-Rama project. You can read other Portland blogger’s take on local soups at Edible Obsessions, The Blueberry Files, Vrai-lean-uh, and Eat Here, Go There. […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: